8 Most Common New Landlord Mistakes

Ryan stetson • June 4, 2025

8 Most Common New Landlord Mistakes

1. Learn Landlord-Tenant Laws

As a landlord, you commit to legally binding responsibilities. For example, urgent plumbing repairs must be completed within 24 to 48 hours and non-urgent plumbing issues must be completed within 7 days. Violating a tenant’s rights can lead to stress, fines, and a bad reputation as a landlord. Here’s what Austin landlords need to know.

2. Complete a Background Check

Even if you’re the best judge of character, a background check and tenant screening are essential. Verifying credit, employment, and rental history provides peace of mind and reduces risk. As much as you’re eager to get income flowing, it’s worth the wait. 

3. Don’t Write Your Own Lease

Back to Landlord-Tenant laws, you can’t just write your own lease. If you do, it won’t be legally binding. Keep things simple by using a standard lease agreement and have your attorney or property manager add relevant amendments. For example, pet policies and furniture and amenities included with rent. 

4. Budget For Vacancies and Maintenance Costs

Set aside at least a few months of rent for maintenance and repairs and continue to add to this fund each month. This way you don’t have to scramble when essential repairs arise. It also provides a cushion for when you have a vacancy and turnover expenses. 

5. Know Who To Call

On that same note, not knowing who to call when repair expenses arise is one of the top landlord mistakes. You don’t just need to know who to call, you need someone who comprehends your compliance requirements as a landlord. 

6. Timely Communication and Documentation

You should keep detailed records with the time and date for every interaction you have with tenants and third-party contractors. If it’s easier, communicate primarily by email or text message. It’s also wise to follow up phone calls with email confirmation of the discussion and obligations. 

7. Know Where to Market Your Property

Your property may be highly competitive, but if you don’t get it in front of the right prospects, you’ll have longer vacancies. You may also miss out on your ideal tenant. Don’t rely on word of mouth, community boards, friends, and neighbors, you need to market your property online. 

8. Don’t Do It All Yourself

To maximize profits, many new landlords manage their own property. However, partnering with a property manager helps you avoid the common mistakes above—and many more! Most landlords find that our services pay for themselves. 

Avoid The Newbie Landlord Mistakes Above

Stetson Management provides white-glove property management services. This includes ensuring full compliance, comprehensive rent reviews, advising on amenities and upgrades, and listing your rental properties on industry-only marketing channels. We have a secure online portal to streamline and simplify landlord and tenant communication. 

Reach out to discuss how we can maximize your property! 


Austin rental property interior with fresh paint
By Ryan stetson June 11, 2026
Learn how often to repaint a rental property in Austin, TX. Discover how fresh paint can increase rent, attract better tenants, and reduce vacancy.
#1 Austin Property Management Company award badge recognizing Stetson Property Management by Propert
By Ryan stetson June 3, 2026
What is the best property management company in Austin, TX? Stetson Property Management was ranked #1 by PropertyManagement.com
Resident benefits package showing credit reporting, identity protection, utility coverage, HVAC filt
By Ryan stetson May 18, 2026
How tenant fee stacking and resident benefit packages can impact tenant retention and rental property performance in the Austin area.
How Much Does Stetson Property Management Cost? | 2026 Round Rock Pricing
By Ryan stetson May 13, 2026
A transparent guide to Stetson Property Management fees in Round Rock, TX. Learn about our $125 flat-fee model, leasing costs, and why we never markup maintenance.
Modern Austin property management office with Stetson Property Management branding
By Ryan stetson May 4, 2026
Learn how to switch property management companies in Austin, TX without disrupting tenants or cash flow. Step-by-step guide for rental property owners.
glori-stetson-property-repairs.jpg
By Ryan stetson April 28, 2026
Learn how rental property maintenance is handled in Austin, TX and how Stetson Property Management keeps repairs efficient, and stress-free for property owners.
Single-family rental home in Austin Texas managed by Stetson Property Management
By Ryan stetson April 17, 2026
Should you hire a local property management company in Austin, Texas? Learn the key differences, benefits, and how to choose the right property manager.
Tenants with pets outside a rental home in Austin Texas, showing a pet-friendly property with dogs
By Ryan stetson April 9, 2026
Should landlords allow pets in Austin, Texas? Learn how pet-friendly rental policies can reduce vacancy, attract better tenants, and protect your investment.
Austin property management cost comparison showing 8 to 10 percent fee vs 125 dollar flat fee for re
By Ryan stetson April 1, 2026
How much does property management cost in Austin, TX? Learn the difference between 8–10% fees and flat-rate pricing from a local Round Rock property mgmt.
Austin rental home with for rent sign representing property value and rental pricing in Austin Texas
By Ryan stetson March 25, 2026
Learn how much rent you can charge for your Austin home, what impacts pricing, and how to maximize rental income in today’s market.